It would seem that we have a logical mind, a reasoning cognition. This is something that is a part of humanity for some purpose, whether you believe it evolved as part of us or was a gift. There is a second part of us which is unthinking. It is instinctual, animal. It drives us with great power, but without thought. I believe to separate the two causes a false dichotomy. Such a division of the mind is, to my way of thinking, not an appropriate avenue for us. This would then mean that the person who acts unthinkingly at all times is not fully human, although there are times when this is certainly appropriate.
Perhaps it duality is not even enough and there is more of a plurality. There are emotional states. There is the ration, the logic. There are inclinations, instincts tied to both. But these forces do not operate independently of on another. They are not separated by an impermeable vacuum and there isn’t a clear switch that allows us to use one without the influence of the others. We may believe this to be so when we use these different modes of thought. The modes of thought which I would list as Logical, Emotional and Instinctual possess a simultaneous exclusivity. This is to say, whereas we feel like they may be exclusive of each other thy actually operate simultaneously with each other. One or the other may be in the forefront, but the others continue to operate in a less powerful manner, in the background so to speak.
When I wrote on the Matter of Eternity to an acquaintance of mine, she related the Zen Buddhist parable of the tea cup which was purposely overfilled, the moral being the emptiness of self as the only way to become full; as well as the universal reality as a canvas and us as paint. I got the feeling that her main point was the denial of self. The empty cup, so that it can be filled with the way, the blank canvas which can be painted. When we discover this truth our self will be annihilated and we will cease to exist as such. I should mention that these are things that I’ve studied, things I’ve experienced, but none of the results from these endeavours has been satisfactory to me. A minor theme in her examples is interdependence, the simultaneous exclusivity. I don’t think this was the point she was trying to make, but it is there. The paint does exist, it does cover the canvas, once it’s there, it will always leave an imprint. The painting is reliant on both the paint and the canvas. The cup in its own way is as dependent on being filled as the tea is on having a vessel to fill. This leaves the existence of myself as intrinsic to the existence of any higher power in the sense that you’re trying to communicate. To date there has been only one thing that I have been able to establish with certainty, and that is that I do exist. The nature of my existence and my relationship with other things is not something of which I’m completely sure. I cannot be entirely certain of Dao/Brahman/God, but I can be certain of this.
And so we see in a broader way the theme of this simultaneous exclusivity. I seems separate from the planet I live on but there is interrelation and this is even dependent upon perspective. For a being which is larger than our planet, perhaps which eats planets, humans may not even be noticeable or may be of little concern to such a being. So all things have the appearance of being divisible when in fact they are all co, or at the very least interdependent. What person has the right to establish divisions in the world? Whether you believe it was created by God(s) or is evolved naturally, it has an order of its own. If a person creates false dichotomies to please themselves they are either claiming to be as wise as God(s) or attempting to abrogate the laws of nature.
No comments:
Post a Comment