Monday, December 20, 2010
Theology: Corpus of the Unknowable
Belief: Orthodoxy
Whether it is orthodoxy or orthopraxy, the restrictive dogmas of religion creates an orthopedic mentality. It supports the weak of spirit. It creates a refuge for those who need others to think their most profound and intimate thoughts for them. What have we to fear from differing beliefs? If their beliefs are wrong and ours right, we’ve lost nothing by acceptance. What have we to fear from differing practices? If their practices are wrong and ours right, what have we lost? Yes, acceptance, not tolerance. Tolerance with its implication of unpleasant suffering of difference. No, our acceptance of others will lead us forward and for every individual who is strong of spirit, it will make them stronger, for while orthodoxy and orthopraxy make us rigid and brittle, the distillations which heterodoxy and heteropraxy can provide us with are the only true path forward. How to know what to do? Follow the Way, listen to the Logos.
Sunday, December 19, 2010
Belief: Reason in Religion
”They all err ,” al-Maarri said, and so shall you if you believe what you know to be wrong. So many will tell you things, doctrines and dogmas which you know to be false. They’ll tell you that this is the truth and if you want the rewards they promise, you’ll have to believe the things they tell you. But if those dogmas and doctrines are contrary to your reason then you’ll never be a true believer anyway. You’ll always be plagued by doubt. You’ll always be haunted by the vacuous guilt inside you. Believe in what you know to be true, follow the Way, listen to the Logos. Listen to the good counsel and shun bad advice. Look at things which can be known and draw your own conclusions. And so he said:
Had they been left alone with reason,
they would not have accepted a spoken lie;
but the whips were raised to strike them.
Traditions were brought to them,
and they were ordered to say,
"We have been told the truth";
If they refused, the sword was drenched with their blood.
They were terrified by scabbards of calamities,
and tempted by great bowls of food,
Offered in a lofty and condescending manner.
Saturday, December 18, 2010
Politics:Universal Education
Our nation has long prided itself on strength of character and worth of merit. We have told generations of children that when they are of age they will be able to achieve whatever it is to which they set their mind. This is only half the truth and concealing the entirety of the truth does a great disservice to our youth. The remainder of the truth is that accomplishment requires education. It is also the truth that education requires capital. The quality of education and level achieved are often the result of the amount of capital attributed to an individual. There have been attempts to reform the student loan system and these attempts are laudable. They are not, however, enough.
After the standard grade school education which every child is provided with, each student is theoretically faced with a choice between the higher general education and vocational education in a specific trade. Higher education and vocational education both occupy important strata in the continuing success of our civilization. The choice between them isn’t the real decision. The true choice is the method of payment for general and vocational education. The true argument is not whether to choose general or vocational education, but how to ensure that every person has the chance to attain the highest level of education they are capable of achieving.
The very ideals of our society, the Athenian ideals of freedom and equality, were conceived on the backs of slaves. Slaves bore the brunt of the tradecraft and skilled labor. In modern society, this is not only unpalatable, it is psychologically unsound. A freeman has a stronger work ethic when motivated properly. Our society has come closer to classlessness than most in history. It has been a conscious progression, but the progress will end if some further steps are not taken. Arguments have been made, the premise of which are that either general education or vocational education should receive funding and take precedence in the minds of educational administrators. But this argument is a distraction. It assumes that the average American has can afford to choose between general and vocational education.
Every person should be afforded to pursue education to the highest extent. Without truly egalitarian opportunity for advanced education our society is doomed to be dominated by a caste system. It has been related that sixty percent of the American population holds less than four percent of the nation’s wealth. Can we afford to assume that these impoverished Americans truly have the ability to choose between a general or vocational education? When it comes time to decide between the two, it’s likely that they’ll choose whichever educational route is cheaper, ends sooner and will begin to reap monetary benefit more quickly. This will likely be the vocational school and this economic coercion strips the majority of Americans of any true choice between general and vocational education. Only by affording the ability to become learned and to be able to make proper decisions can we be sure that all Americans have been granted the opportunity to succeed. Not everyone will feel the need to pursue this higher education, but if there is no chance for them to do so, there is no way to know what they might’ve become. Vocational schools are necessary institutions. Skilled craftsmen are essential to the operation of every civilization and this fact should not be overlooked, but it is critical that we understand one additional fact. If we are to become a place where liberty and equality are true values and not empty buzzwords then we must make every effort to ensure that the economically average and below-average person has the same opportunity to acquire education as the above-average person. The first step toward the furthering of these American values is universal education.
This opportunity, the chance to attain whatever education is desired, should be extended to all citizens, under the Reformed Citizenship Program. Those true Citizens of our nation who are willing to serve the common good should be rewarded with the opportunity to better themselves. This may appear to be abandoning one class system for another, and it is. It is leaving the class system based on money behind for a class system based on merit, system in which those who desire to succeed in life are afforded the opportunity to do so. They will be free to become the equals of every other citizen. The strength of a nation willing to invest in education cannot be discounted. When the Prussians suffered military defeat at the hands of Napoleon, it spurred an educational reform, not a military reform. They revived the study of the classics of Greece and Rome , their Education Minister stating the “the Greeks are our models and our teachers for all that is good and that is useful and for all that we would like to see in ourselves brought to perfection.” The equal opportunity for education is the cornerstone of a great nation, and this privilege should be extended to every single person in this nation who has the common good in their heart.
In short, compatriots, universal education is catchphrase which is used to describe the idea of every person being granted the opportunity to continue learning in professional institutions. In other words, free college. This opportunity should be granted regardless of class, color, sex or financial background. If this sounds revolutionary, it is. If it sounds new it isn’t. Thomas Paine, one of the founding fathers of the United States was also a believer in universal education. In accordance with the founding values that America be a land of opportunity for all, a program should be implemented allowing all citizens of the United States to attain the highest educational level they desire. Most people would agree with this. The quarrel they’d have is in the question: and how shall the People pay for such a program?
Theology: Fear of the Sun
We should never be afraid to allow our holidays, meditations, prayers or observances synchronize with natural phenomena. To pray or meditate as the sun rises is not the same as worshipping the sun. If one believes that the universe was created by the Unknowable, then the order created by it is an emanation of its power, and not something with which one should be afraid of associating. If one does not believe in this manner, but rather is performing meditational practices and searching for an opportune time do so, what better times could there be for cultivating the feeling of proper timing than practicing during naturally occurring astral or earthly phenomena. If one is a believer in god(s) then the occurrences are part of the order they/it created. If one only believes in the natural world then it makes even more sense to observe these astral and earthly events. Let’s not fear association with the orders and cycles of life.
Friday, December 17, 2010
Generations: Lost in Translation
There is a general misunderstanding of my intent and I believe the intent of my generation. I had the unfortunate experience of reading a “field guide” to my generation, in Fortune Magazine entitled “Manage Us? Puh-leeze…” My fist issue with this article was the term Generation Y. The unoriginality is striking, honestly, it’s just the next letter after X the name of the previous generation. It should be Generation Why in my opinion. This is because I, and others, are not afraid to ask why those who preceded us are in the state of general disarray that they are. Why to they lack morals, yet claim them? Why are they duplicitous pathological liars. Why do they ignore reality and sell an imaginary world future? I have a lot of questions about the members of previous generations in Management. Why do they lack the basic skills necessary for leadership? Why do they observe the goings on of their subordinates and yet ignore them? And finally, do they think I’m stupid?
Do they honestly think that because I’m young I have no Idea what they’re doing? I, unlike them, have indeed reviewed the classics. I’ve studied the master’s writings and observed them in action. I can tell the difference between, in the vulgar, absolute bullshit and honesty. This may seem a little harsh, but what has happened with the abandonment of knowledge and the building of phony corporate systems of excellence on this knowledgless foundation of sand is that a disingenuous culture of nonsense has taken root. Now the members of this culture of nonsense are unable to understand why I and others aren’t buying into or even particularly interested in buying into this culture. Articles such as this don’t help because they only describe what is happening and not why. That’s really the most important question to Generation Why, if you ask me. Why should I invest myself in adapting a corporate culture of duplicity? Isn’t the reason I took this job to make money so that I can do something I actually enjoy with it? You see, I’m more grounded in reality than the members of those previous generations who have become absorbed by the kraken of bureaucracy. They’ve become so pompous that they even forget the ideals that this country was founded on, those ideals which must be thought of critically.
When a powerful wealthy manager places a sign on a parking spot to claim it as theirs in perpetuity, they’ve destroyed the idea of equality. They aren’t protecting the rights of the disabled, as in the case of a handicapped parking space, or preserving the ability to respond to an emergency, as in the case of a fire lane. They aren’t even enforcing a federal, state, county or city ordinance. They’re only trying to protect their sense of entitlement. It’s commonly believed that people of my generation feel a sense of entitlement and this is true, but not in the way that it is initially thought. I do feel entitled. I feel entitled to be heard as an equal in existence. I feel entitled to the knowledge that those in power are acting to protect those who are at a disadvantage and for the public good. When I see an assigned parking space I feel a sense of revulsion, but then I’m usually pegged as a rebel.
Politics:The Responsibilities of Citizenship
Our founding fathers went to great pains and suffered much derision to establish a nation where liberty and equality before the law was a reality. Much violence was visited upon them in the battle to forge a union of states where all men were guaranteed rights. Much violence was again suffered to keep this union together and to ensure that the guarantee of rights passed from theory to actuality. Our fathers assumed that the rights they guaranteed would be understood as the second side of a coin. On this second side of the coin was inscribed “E Pluribus Unum,” Out of Many One. This was our motto until very recently, and with good reason was it our national watchword. Our founders understood that rights must be borne on the shoulders of responsibility. They believed this to be so intrinsic a value that it need not be recorded, but in this belief they were remiss. The society they established was revolutionary and spawned a culture they could not have predicted. It begat a national mindset of entitlement, where people believe they are worthy of the privileges of citizenship without needing to contribute to the nation whatever. I tell you truly, this is not the case. All citizens of this nation must contribute to it, and in return they shall be granted the rights which have been guaranteed by our fathers.
The reasons for the necessity of this change in worldview are thus, those who believe they are entitled to benefits without contribution have become the degraders of our society. Our proposal is not unthinkable, it is not unheard of, it is not difficult. We propose that the recorded rights of a citizen be tempered by recording the responsibilities of a citizen. We further propose that those responsibilities be as follows; every person, upon reaching the age of majority in this nation and desiring to become a citizen with all the rights thereof, shall submit to a term of national service. This service is a demonstration of willingness to serve a good greater than the self, proof of their love not only for the nation, but for their fellow man. For this national service shall not be limited to the military branches, as many nations have been want to make it, but it ought to extend to a neglected arm of the government as well. A group of individuals banded together for the peaceable improvement of society, through the building of schools, roads and hospitals. The intent and result will be the same, whether the service is by arms or by activity, it will be to steel the hearts and minds of those who want to be Americans, in the values of America . Those desiring to become citizens shall also agree that they will remain in the reserve of this service until a much later age, so that they can instill the youth of the nation with the same fervor and so that they may remain capable of service in time of national need, such as invasion or disaster. These citizens shall also agree that, having strived so stridently to gain citizenship, they shall never fail to use the rights gained by it. They shall vote in every election without fail, and thereby make their voice be heard. They shall be eased in doing so by the creation of a holiday of the highest import. A day in which no citizen works, but all citizens vote.
The lifestyle a citizen leads after he or she fulfills the responsibilities of citizenship is a choice for them alone. Within the limits of the common law they shall never be derided for the choices they make, they shall not be looked at askew, for they have become part of something greater than one, they are the many. This is not to say those who are not citizens of our nation shall have no rights whatever, they shall. But most importantly, they shall have no vote. For without demonstrating a willingness to serve the people of these United States, they have demonstrated that they do not have the good of the many in mind, and are thereby not worthy of casting a vote in matters of import for the many. Nor shall we limit citizenship to those born within our borders, but ought to extend it , to any person willing to serve for a term in the federal services, any person willing to demonstrate their desires for citizenship. The best of the world should know that these States are a meritocracy, where men and women can contribute and be rewarded for their service.
Philosophy: False Dichotomy of the Mind
It would seem that we have a logical mind, a reasoning cognition. This is something that is a part of humanity for some purpose, whether you believe it evolved as part of us or was a gift. There is a second part of us which is unthinking. It is instinctual, animal. It drives us with great power, but without thought. I believe to separate the two causes a false dichotomy. Such a division of the mind is, to my way of thinking, not an appropriate avenue for us. This would then mean that the person who acts unthinkingly at all times is not fully human, although there are times when this is certainly appropriate.
Perhaps it duality is not even enough and there is more of a plurality. There are emotional states. There is the ration, the logic. There are inclinations, instincts tied to both. But these forces do not operate independently of on another. They are not separated by an impermeable vacuum and there isn’t a clear switch that allows us to use one without the influence of the others. We may believe this to be so when we use these different modes of thought. The modes of thought which I would list as Logical, Emotional and Instinctual possess a simultaneous exclusivity. This is to say, whereas we feel like they may be exclusive of each other thy actually operate simultaneously with each other. One or the other may be in the forefront, but the others continue to operate in a less powerful manner, in the background so to speak.
When I wrote on the Matter of Eternity to an acquaintance of mine, she related the Zen Buddhist parable of the tea cup which was purposely overfilled, the moral being the emptiness of self as the only way to become full; as well as the universal reality as a canvas and us as paint. I got the feeling that her main point was the denial of self. The empty cup, so that it can be filled with the way, the blank canvas which can be painted. When we discover this truth our self will be annihilated and we will cease to exist as such. I should mention that these are things that I’ve studied, things I’ve experienced, but none of the results from these endeavours has been satisfactory to me. A minor theme in her examples is interdependence, the simultaneous exclusivity. I don’t think this was the point she was trying to make, but it is there. The paint does exist, it does cover the canvas, once it’s there, it will always leave an imprint. The painting is reliant on both the paint and the canvas. The cup in its own way is as dependent on being filled as the tea is on having a vessel to fill. This leaves the existence of myself as intrinsic to the existence of any higher power in the sense that you’re trying to communicate. To date there has been only one thing that I have been able to establish with certainty, and that is that I do exist. The nature of my existence and my relationship with other things is not something of which I’m completely sure. I cannot be entirely certain of Dao/Brahman/God, but I can be certain of this.
And so we see in a broader way the theme of this simultaneous exclusivity. I seems separate from the planet I live on but there is interrelation and this is even dependent upon perspective. For a being which is larger than our planet, perhaps which eats planets, humans may not even be noticeable or may be of little concern to such a being. So all things have the appearance of being divisible when in fact they are all co, or at the very least interdependent. What person has the right to establish divisions in the world? Whether you believe it was created by God(s) or is evolved naturally, it has an order of its own. If a person creates false dichotomies to please themselves they are either claiming to be as wise as God(s) or attempting to abrogate the laws of nature.
Theology:Take it to the Limit
You must ask your self some questions. Are you capable of saying what god is? Most people readily admit that they cannot. When it comes to describing what God is not, however, most people will quickly tell you things they’ve imagined. God is not bad, only good, they say. God is not part of this world but is part of a higher world, they say. The very minute that you say God is not something, you have placed a limit on it. Since god would be beyond Human understanding then limits couldn’t be placed on it. God would be completely beyond our reckoning. This means that we must use extraordinary reasoning in order to come close to understanding anything near what God could be. God could be a part of me and much more. Think of things beyond your ability to understand. You can understand another person so God probably wouldn’t be limited to being one of us. You can grasp the idea that surrounds nothing so God probably wouldn’t be limited to being nothing. You have a vague idea of what being everything would entail so God most likely wouldn’t be only everything either. We could go on like this for quite some time. God would be everything and nothing. Infinite and Finite. Alive and Dead. You and Me. Rocks and Trees. Stars and water. The vacuum of space. Light and Darkness. Good and Evil. Truth and Lies. God encompasses more than we can possibly fathom and also nothing at all. There would be no Devil, only God. There would be no angels, only God. There would be no humans, Only God. There would be nothing at all in the Universe except God.
Theology: What is Its Nature?
The particular issue we are addressing here is faith. I have long wrestled with efforts to address the questions regarding faith in a more powerful being. I will discuss the idea of a more powerful being using the English word god for now. Most scriptures will tell us that god is not limited, yet they then begin to place limitations on God by describing God and insisting on their particular description being used exclusively. The use of “he” as a pronoun is an initial problem. God, if it is not limited, is most certainly not a man or a woman. The pronoun “it” could be used to avoid gender specificity but it leaves us with the implication that god is a thing, which god, most likely, is not limited to being. It is probably wiser to use god as its own pronoun. This thing has many names; The Lord, Christ, The Holy Spirit, Allah, Enlil, Ahuramazda, Marduk, Ra, Aton, Tao, The Jade Emperor, Zeus, Buddha, Lord Lao, Brahman, Vishnu, Ganesh, Jehovah, Yahweh, Elohim. All of these names are used to describe the same idea. The existence of so many varied names proves that the name that we call god is not as important as what we are describing.
Having established a nomenclature to use in our discussion we can return to the question: what is the nature of god? Is god omnipotent as the Abrahamic traditions say, or is god merely more potent than a human? In a later part of this discussion I will talk about a conversation regarding the creation of matter in depth but for now we’ll settle on a conversation I had with some Mormon missionaries. We talked about the nature of god and they agreed that god was omniscient and omnipotent. We were discussing the “Matter of Eternity” and they stated that the belief in their church is that god didn’t create something from nothing, that god created people from clay and the universe from matter that already existed. God can’t, they said, just create something from nothing. That makes sense, I replied, but wouldn’t that limit god’s potency? I continued, were god incapable of creating something from nothing god would not be infinitely powerful, god would be merely powerful enough to create the universe from matter. This is certainly more powerful than a human, but not all powerful by any means. This is a clear example of the misguided and incomplete thought which is penetrating most of the efforts in this field. The entirety of the idea had not been thought through by them. All of the implications of it weren’t brought in into focus by my missionary friends.
Is this Thing Conscious or unconscious? The unthinking aspect of Daoism is, in truth, what attracted me to it originally. I have heard, although I cannot specify the source, that we are never truly as human as when we are at play. That is, that we are not thinking. Some would say that God is loving and actively shaping our destiny. Others would say that Dao is not a conscious entity but pervasive and binding nonetheless. Being merely a human, and using extraordinary reasoning, I am inclined to believe that God is not so easily explained. It would most likely be something approximating both consciousness and unconsciousness; sometimes actively participating in the universe, sometimes watching, sometimes unthinking, but most probably all at once. Since God is beyond our reckoning, none of these terms would really be accurate in describing its actions.
Theology: This is Madness
I may be insane, and by the time you finish reading this you may be too. Sanity, for our purposes will be described as a state of mind, which uses reason, which does not possess any delusional properties. This state of mind is one in which a person is able to approach the world around them with a modicum of ration. A sane person, for the purposes of this argument is one who addresses the problems in front of them using logic; at least a version of the Socratic method. When they encounter a problem, they asked themselves questions and come to the most reasonable conclusion. An insane person, would then be a person who, although making observations, comes to a conclusion about something which does not correlate with them. An insane person does not use reason to come to a final decision on issues they are pondering.
Let us assume that there is a god, this will be easy for some of you and others will have to go along with the idea for the sake of this exercise. The question then is: what is the nature of god? I believe that god is not something that can be understood logically. In order to come close to an understanding of its nature we must lose our sanity, abandon our reason.
Reason is a tool which humans are able to use to bring order to the world around them. Whether the world has a natural order or if humankind is meant to place its own order on it is not something we will discuss. One of the most prolific examples in the use of reason is the archetypal Socrates. In the Crito, by Plato, Socrates analyzes the idea surrounding the justice of his own execution. After deciding that people cannot live a happy life without justice, that injustice cannot be allowed under any circumstances, and that evil cannot be repaid with evil without incurring injustice, he concludes that escaping Athens would be repaying the injustice of his conviction after he had consented to live by the laws of Athens by maintaining his citizenship there. This is a heroic example of using reason, and following the process through to its natural conclusion. This is what I would call sanity. Even though he abandons self preservation in this line of logic, these are ideas that a mind can encompass.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)